Your Guide to Multi-Carrier Shipping  

by Simon Unicomb, 30 March 2022

What do you do when you need a new shirt? 

Some people might go straight for a brand they already like - maybe they’ve bought shirts there before, or even a pair of jeans. Maybe they buy all of their clothes from that one store, but  when the majority of us shop for clothing, we usually buy from a variety of different stores. Perhaps we prefer to buy shirts from Kmart, but H&M has a better selection of sweaters. 

All in all, we mostly recognise that when we stick to a single provider, we can be losing out on a better quality product or a better deal. Many believe that the same is true for shipping: by limiting ourselves to a single carrier, we may be cutting ourselves off from options that would suit us better.

In action, this principle of ‘shopping around’ is called multi-carrier shipping, and we use it to get better service depending on our specific shipping needs. Today, we’re taking you through everything you need to know about multi-carrier shipping: what it is, the pros and cons, and how it differs from other methods.  

What is Multi-Carrier Shipping? 

Multi-carrier shipping is the opposite of single carrier shipping - which is where you rely on a single carrier / freight division to fulfil all of your shipping needs. You may also have heard it called ‘Aggregate shipping’.  In a multi carrier solution, software compares a range of different carriers’ quotes and benefits in order to find the best fit for your particular shipment. This same software usually tracks the freight proceedings. 

How is it Different From Other Methods?

Single carrier shipping relies either on the use of  a business’ personal fleet or a private agreement with a single carrier, whereas multi-carrier shipping uses a web of carriers to fulfil a business’ shipping needs. 

Very big companies with fleets large enough to sustain their operations, and small companies without the demand to sustain a multi carrier solution will likely be satisfied with a single carrier solution, but multi-carrier shipping offers a range of benefits to those in between: who require a degree flexibility in their services that a single carrier simply cannot provide. 

The Benefits of Multi-Carrier Shipping

Multi-carrier shipping can be an excellent way for businesses to improve efficiency and minimise risk across their operations. We’ve listed out some of the main advantages of this method below: 

  • Optimisation of Service Type 

No carrier service can realistically be big enough to support the full range of shipping options you may want or need access to, such as next day delivery, delivery to remote locations, shipping, trucking, and many more services. For businesses that ship a variety of different products or to a variety of locations, the ability to shop around for the right carrier can prove very valuable: allowing you to both weigh up the expertise provided by the carrier and their quote against competitors to find the right fit. Therefore, multi-carrier shipping gives you the choice to entrust a specialised carrier with the job that you need done - allowing for both more flexibility and ability to meet the demands of customers. 

  • Less risk of disruption 

A single carrier option can effectively place all your eggs in a single basket, meaning that when your sole carrier faces delays, disruptions, or any of the common nuisances that plague the transportation industry - the entirety of your operations will be impacted. In a multi carrier system, the risk is minimised and remains local to only one aspect of operations and can be negated through proactive rerouting. This allows for better and more agile performance across your business. 

  • More control  

We know that every time an order is placed, our reputation is on the line with that customer - and it’s up to us to fulfil their expectations and provide great service. Multi-carrier shipping allows for much more control over the service that we provide, as we are able to exercise more choice in which carrier we choose for which operation. 

  • Data consolidation 

Multi-carrier shipping requires sophisticated software to pull off - and this software also collects data which can be useful for future analysis. This data allows businesses to understand the strengths and weaknesses both within their own processes and the particular carriers they choose, allowing them to fine tune their operations and gain efficiency over time. 

Disadvantages of Multi-Carrier Shipping

Going for a multi carrier solution also isn’t going to be perfect for every business’ needs. Below are a few of the reasons that may lead you to look into other methods: 

  • Greater logistical demands 

Coordinating between multiple carriers, even with helpful software to aid in the process, does introduce new logistical demands and challenges for businesses. For those with small teams already stretched thin, it may not be the time to make the switch. 

  • Price 

For smaller businesses, multi-carrier shipping can be a less cost effective choice. Multi-carrier shipping requires specific software to be done well and, depending on the provider, this can pose a barrier for entry to some businesses. Additionally, small businesses often benefit from discounts given by individual providers in exchange for an exclusive relationship - which can widen profit margins considerably. 

  • Not right for every business 

As much as multi-carrier shipping can open up new opportunities and allow for increased efficiency, no system will be the right choice for every business. For instance, businesses with very localised shipping needs, infrequent orders, or needs that generally rely on one system  or method of transportation may be entirely satisfied with a single carrier solution which offers the specific service they require. 

The Right Solution For You?

Although it’s not perfect for everyone, we think that multi-carrier shipping is a great choice for many businesses who want to improve their efficiency and reliability. If you have more questions about multi-carrier shipping, or any aspect of the shipping process, get in touch with us at TransVirtual today.

Your Quick Guide to Less Than Truckload Shipping?

by Matt Corby, 10 June 2022

Every year, the market in the United States alone for less than truckload (LTL) shipping is worth more than $86 billion. Of course, not everybody is familiar with less than truckload shipping and what it entails. However, based on how big this market is, you can be sure that it...

Freight Bidding (And How to Do it Right!) 

by Cameron Craig, 9 June 2022

Nothing strikes fear into the heart of a mild-mannered transportation professional like freight bidding season. And we get it: freight bidding can often be a complex, stressful, and unsatisfying process for everyone involved.  But the great news is that it doesn’t have to be that way. Freight bidding can be...

Answering Your Charge-Per-Mile Delivery Questions

by Murray Phillips, 8 June 2022

Charge or not to charge? It’s not the most glamorous aspect of running a business, but determining your rates is an important part of making sure that your operation is profitable. There are a few different approaches to this issue, and today we’re breaking down one of the most common...

How to Implement Contactless Delivery

by Cameron Craig, 7 June 2022

Learn how to improve driver and consumer safety during COVID-19 with contactless delivery COVID-19 has become a major risk to driver and consumer safety, hasn’t it?  The trouble is, it also led us all into a delivery boom which requires more drivers to be at more doors every single day....

What is a Freight Broker and when do you need one?

by Matt Corby, 6 June 2022

There are so many moving parts in transport management, aren’t there? And there are just as many ways to waste time, money, and incur damage. One thing’s clear: not all freight management systems are created equal. Successful companies rely on a freight broker to handle their shipping logistics, especially during...

What is centralised dispatching and how does it work?

by Simon Unicomb, 1 June 2022

In 2020, e-commerce sales accounted for nearly 15% of the world’s total retail spending. Now if that doesn’t seem like a lot, what if I told you that means close to $4 trillion of spending every year? Online shopping is fast outpacing brick-and-mortar stores. But what does that mean for...

  • Rated 4.9 / 5

A must-have tool for running a profitable transport and delivery business.

Want a full-featured transport management system that makes your delivery business simple? Save time, lower costs and move your freight faster with TransVirtual’s tools for businesses big and small.